Wednesday, October 19, 2005

All part of the scientific process? Part 1

Peer review - "[it is] all part of the scientific process," said Dr. Michael Behe, today. As he has done for other scientists, one "reviews results...techniques... conclusions."

It has been stated here before that Behe has not submitted his own work on intelligent design for peer review. At the same time, Behe agreed, when asked by plaintiff's counsel Eric Rothschild if the "peer review for Darwin's Black Box was analogous to peer review in the [scientific] literature." It was, according to Behe, even more rigorous. There were more than twice standard the number of reviewers and "they read [the book] more carefully... because this was a controversial topic."

One such reviewer, said Behe, was Dr. Michael Atchison, head of biochemistry at the University of Pennsylvania veterinary school. "He was selected," Behe said, "because he was the instructor of the editor's wife." While Behe was not in touch with him, "Professor Atchison contacted [Behe]...after the book came out."

Really?

Rothschild introduced this article by Professor Atichison, for the purposes of impeachment.

The editor [of Darwin's Black Box]was not certain that this manuscript was a good risk for publication. There were clearly theological issues at hand, and he was under the impression that these issues would be poorly received by the scientific community...

The editor shared his concerns with his wife. His wife was a student in my class. She advised her husband to give me a call. So, unaware of all this, I received a phone call from the publisher in New York. We spent approximately 10 minutes on the phone. After hearing a description of the work, I suggested that the editor should seriously consider publishing the manuscript...It sounded like this Behe fellow might have some good ideas, although I could not be certain since I had never seen the manuscript. We hung up and I never thought about it again. At least until two years later.


"Is this your understanding of the kind of peer review that Dr. Atcheson did of your book?" "No," Behe replied. Rothschild continued, "he didn't review it carefully… he didn't review it at all." Behe: "My understanding is different."

Atchison goes on in his article, using the events described to imply that God's will played a role in leading the editor to him and in his own encouragement of the publication of Behe's book.

Is this the sort of rigorous peer review that science dictates?

Also on the subject of scientific discourse, Behe repeated his oft quoted statement: "I've considered [peer-reviewed scientific conferences] to be a poor forum for discussing such ideas" because "you can't just present ID in an abbreviated fashion." Yet, when pressed, Behe still insisted that a high school classroom would provide an adequate forum "to mention [such] topics that [students] can pursue outside of the classroom."

submitted by Amy Laura Cahn, Community Education Organizer, ACLU of Pennsylvania

51 Comments:

Blogger Unknown said...

Greetings

Very interesting blog - keep up the excellent work!

Sarah

9:34 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Brilliant! I can't wait to see what happened next.

11:28 PM  
Blogger Rd1-d2 said...

Great work! Please keep us posted.

11:49 PM  
Blogger FishyFred said...

I am not even close to a lawyer: What does "for the purpose of impeachment" mean? Is it to prove a witness wrong?

1:51 AM  
Blogger JM O'Donnell said...

That's pretty much trial over. The only person left with any credibility in the entire ID movement is Behe and he just sunk his own battleship.

1:59 PM  
Blogger Chanchal said...

Download the Discovery app · Open the app · Sign in · Visit discovery.com/activate Select the TV provider. To activate Discovery , visit discovery.com/activateand enter the activation code you get from your device. Choose your TV provider on the app and sign.Stream Discovery on Roku With Discovery , you can watch full episodes and Live TV from Discovery Channel anytime anywhere.If you are a new subscriber, you can redeem your gift card, voucher or promo code by visiting discoveryplus.com/redeem, entering your code and following the step-by-step instructions.discoveryplus.com/activate - Enter the 8-digit code you see on your TV to activate disney plus channel on your device. Steps to find disneyplus begin code.Learn how to connect printer to wifito WiFi so that you can print to it from any device connected to the same network.Connect the printer with a temporary USB connection (Windows) · Search Windows for HP, and then click your printer name from the list of results.For the aol mail login,go to www.mail.AOL.com website and then click on the '​Sign In' option. Provide your username and password to login successfully.

12:50 PM  
Blogger komalweb said...

Norton Antivirus provides protection from viruses, malware, online threats without harming device performance. It also blocks harmful websites. You can get Norton.com/setup product from retail store and also download and install Norton Antivirus with product key from Norton.com/setup. And to do this, you can visit the website given by us at Norton.com/setup or link. Our entire team is available to help you.
Norton.com/setup
Norton.com/setup

4:25 AM  
Blogger komalweb said...

Download the McAfee antivirus Mcafee.com/activate key to protect your device from being spoiled by the harmful viruses as it starts finding the way to remove them from the device as soon as possible.If you have code, you enter mcafee activation code and if you have any problems redeeming your activation code, you can contact our team through this website mcafee.com/activate and get the information Can.For more information, you can visit our website Mcafee.com/activate and enjoy.

4:26 AM  
Blogger komalweb said...

Select the office product you want to download and install on the device. Go to the office.com/setup option. To upgrade Office, press on the products of office.com/setup and start downloading and installing Office products on the device.log in and enter office 25 digit product key to activate your office product. if you are new user then you need to create a office account to get more benefits of office.com/setup subscription.

4:28 AM  
Blogger komalweb said...

Roku Streaming players are an increasingly advantageous roku.com/link and financially savvy approach to sit in front of the TV. Simply plug it into your TV, associate with the web, set up a Roku record, and start spilling your top choices.Roku gadgets are easy to set-up and simple to-utilize. roku.com/link They accompany a straightforward remote, and incredible highlights like Roku Search which makes it easy to discover what you need to watch.

4:28 AM  
Blogger komalweb said...

Download and install canon printer driver from the official site. To do so enter canon printer model number at canon.com/ijsetup.
ij.start.canon
canon.com/ijsetup
ij.start.canon

4:29 AM  
Blogger komalweb said...

website to setup your printer. Get started withyour new printer by downloading the software.We Support you for 123.hp.com/setup Network Printer Connection which can be done by either USB or Wireless Connection.website to setup your printer get started with your new printer by downloading the software.You will be able to connect the printer to a network and print across devices.

4:31 AM  
Blogger komalweb said...

Webroot SecureAnywhere Antivirus is a powerful antivirus, designed to fight malaria and other threats. You can protect your computer, PC, and other devices from malware, viruses, spyware, etc. You can download, install and install webroot via webroot.com/safe . To install Webroot go to webroot.com/safe . If you do not have an account, go to Find My Webroot Account and create an account. If you want to know more about it, then you can visit the webroot.com/safewebsite.

4:32 AM  
Blogger komalweb said...

Download System Mechanic Professional for Windows to optimize, repair, and protect your PC against Internet threats. System Mechanic is a quick, simple way to clear unwanted files from your PC .System Mechanic Download enables the users to make your device perform more efficiently and without any issues. Visit iolo system mechanic downloadand get the software for your device.

4:33 AM  
Blogger komalweb said...

Download System Mechanic Professional for Windows to optimize, repair, and protect your PC against Internet threats. System Mechanic is a quick, simple way to clear unwanted files from your PC .System Mechanic Download enables the users to make your device perform more efficiently and without any issues. Visit system mechanic Download and get the software for your device.

4:34 AM  
Blogger komalweb said...

Amazon Prime TV, and MyTV code. To register your device on the Amazon website you go to our website and enter the given code. The program requires the customer to have an Amazon account and a streaming device or TV. Amazon Prime Video is available on almost all streaming devices like Roku, Amazon Fire TV, Chromecast. For this, you just have to go to Amazon Amazon.com/mytv with the help of the amazon activation code. You can visit our website for details of the entire process. You can do this by installing the Amazon.com/mytv Video application on your smart TV, or the digital media player or video game console connected to your TV by visiting the link provided by us in the de cription.or more information, you can contact our team at amazon.com/mytv and get more and more information.

4:34 AM  
Blogger tanishaweb1 said...

Download and install canon printer driver from the official site. To do so enter canon printer model number at canon.com/ijsetup.
ij.start.canon
ij.start.canon
ij.start.canon
ij.start.canon
ij.start.canon
ij.start.canon
ij.start.canon

5:16 AM  
Blogger tanishaweb1 said...

Webroot SecureAnywhere Antivirus is a powerful antivirus, designed to fight malaria and other threats. You can protect your computer, PC, and other devices from malware, viruses, spyware, etc. You can download, install and install webroot via webroot.com/safe . To install Webroot go to webroot.com/safe . If you do not have an account, go to Find My Webroot Account and create an account. If you want to know more about it, then you can visit the webroot.com/safe website.
webroot.com/safe
webroot.com/safe

5:17 AM  
Blogger tanishaweb1 said...

Download the McAfee antivirus mcafee.com/activate key to protect your device from being spoiled by the harmful viruses as it starts finding the way to remove them from the device as soon as possible.If you have code, you enter mcafee activation code and if you have any problems redeeming your activation code, you can contact our team through this website mcafee.com/activate and get the information Can.For more information, you can visit our website mcafee.com/activate and enjoy.
Mcafee.com/activate
Mcafee.com/activate

5:18 AM  
Blogger tanishaweb1 said...

Norton Antivirus provides protection from viruses, malware, online threats without harming device performance. It also blocks harmful websites. You can get Norton.com/setup product from retail store and also download and install Norton Antivirus with product key from Norton.com/setup. And to do this, you can visit the website given by us at Norton.com/setup or link. Our entire team is available to help you.
Norton.com/setup

5:19 AM  
Blogger tanishaweb1 said...

website to setup your printer. Get started withyour new printer by downloading the software.We Support you for 123 hp com Setup Network Printer Connection which can be done by either USB or Wireless Connection.website to setup your printer get started with your new printer by downloading the software.You will be able to connect the printer to a network and print across devices.
123.hp.com/setup

5:20 AM  
Anonymous shilpi said...

Download and install and office setup from office.com/setup . log in and enter office 25 digit product
key to activate your office product. if you are new user then you need to create a office account to get more benefits of office.com/setup subscription. Ms office is a new sensatin office.com/setup in the market that left every body awestruck with its best
products.
office.com/setup
office.com/setup
office.com/setup
office.com/setup
office.com/setup

1:16 AM  
Anonymous shilpi said...

Norton Antivirus provides protection from viruses, malware, online threats without harming device performance. It also blocks harmful websites. You can get Norton.com/setup product from retail store and also download and install Norton Antivirus with product key
from Norton.com/setup. And to do this, you can visit the website given by us at Norton.com/setup or link. Our entire team is available to help you.
Norton.com/setup
Norton.com/setup
Norton.com/setup
Norton.com/setup

1:17 AM  
Anonymous shilpi said...

You can download and install norton setup from Norton.com/setup . Norton may receive annual renewal billing, cancellations, refunds, subscriptions, credit card
updates, purchases by Norton membership. Visit Norton.com/setup to activate or renew your Norton membership. And a valid Norton membership ensures that your security
is always updated. You should activate or renew your subscription before the trial or membership period ends so that all Norton features can continue to be used and
your computer is protected. For more information, you can contact our team at Norton.com/setup and get more and more information.
Norton.com/setup
Norton.com/setup
Norton.com/setup
Norton.com/setup
Norton.com/setup
Norton.csom/setup

1:18 AM  
Anonymous shilpi said...

Download and install canon printer driver from the official site. To do so enter canon printer model number at canon.com/ijsetup.
ij.start.canon
ij.start.canon
ij.start.canon
ij.start.canon
ij.start.canon
ij.start.canon

1:19 AM  
Anonymous shilpi said...

Download and install canon printer driver from the official site. To do so enter canon printer model number at canon.com/ijsetup.
ij.start.canon
ij.start.canon
ij.start.canon
ij.start.canon



Webroot SecureAnywhere Antivirus is a powerful antivirus, designed to fight malaria and other threats. You can protect your computer, PC, and other devices from
malware, viruses, spyware, etc. You can download, install and install webroot via webroot.com/safe . To install Webroot go to webroot.com/safe . If you do not have an
account, go to Find My Webroot Account and create an account. If you want to know more about it, then you can visit the webroot.com/safe website.
webroot.com/safe

1:19 AM  
Anonymous shilpi said...

Amazon Prime TV, and MyTV code. To register your device on the Amazon website you go to our website and enter the given code. The program requires the customer to have
an Amazon account and a streaming device or TV. Amazon Prime Video is available on almost all streaming devices like Roku, Amazon Fire TV, Chromecast. For this, you
just have to go to Amazon Amazon.com/mytv with the help of the amazon activation code. You can visit our website for details of the entire process. You can do this by
installing the Amazon.com/mytv Video application on your smart TV, or the digital media player or video game console connected to your TV by visiting the link provided
by us in the de cription.or more information, you can contact our team at Amazon.com/mytv and get more and more information.
amazon.com/mytv


Download the McAfee antivirus mcafee.com/activate key to protect your device from being spoiled by the harmful viruses as it starts finding the way to remove them from
the device as soon as possible.If you have code, you enter mcafee activation code and if you have any problems redeeming your activation code, you can contact our team
through this website mcafee.com/activate and get the information Can.For more information, you can visit our website mcafee.com/activate and enjoy.
mcafee.com/activate

1:20 AM  
Blogger pooja said...

Webroot SecureAnywhere Antivirus is a powerful antivirus, designed to fight malaria and other threats. You can protect your computer, PC, and other devices from malware, viruses, spyware, etc. You can download, install and install webroot via webroot.com/safe. To install Webroot go to webroot.com/safe . If you do not have an account, go to Find My Webroot Account and create an account. If you want to know more about it, then you can visit the webroot.com/safe website.

webroot.com/safe
webroot.com/safe
webroot.com/safe

10:47 AM  
Blogger pooja said...

Download the McAfee antivirus Mcafee.com/activate key to protect your device from being spoiled by the harmful viruses as it starts finding the way to remove them from the device as soon as possible.If you have code, you enter mcafee activation code and if you have any problems redeeming your activation code, you can contact our team through this Mcafee.com/activateactivate and get the information Can.For more information, you can visit our website mcafee.com/activate and enjoy.

10:48 AM  
Blogger pooja said...

Download and install canon printer driver from the official site. To do so enter canon printer model number at ij.start.canon.

ij.start.canon
ij.start.canon

10:49 AM  
Blogger pooja said...

Roku Streaming players are an increasingly advantageous roku.com/link and financially savvy approach to sit in front of the TV. Simply plug it into your TV, associate with the web, set up a Roku record, and start spilling your top choices.Roku gadgets are easy to set-up and simple to-utilize. roku/link They accompany a straightforward remote, and incredible highlights like Roku Search which makes it easy to discover what you need to watch.

10:49 AM  
Blogger shivaniweb said...

HP stands for Hewlett-Packard and was a US based company that focused on computer hardware and software, and IT services and consulting. ... HP Inc focuses on the PC and printers business while HPE targets the enterprise products market and services.hp.com/123

11:30 PM  
Blogger shivaniweb said...

Hulu is an on-demand video streaming platform that has been around for more than a decade. It's one of the best and largest streaming platformshulu.com/activate

11:31 PM  
Blogger shivaniweb said...

"Microsoft 365 is the productivity cloud designed to help you pursue your passion and run your business. More than just apps like Word, Excel, PowerPoint, Microsoft 365 brings together best-in-class productivity apps with powerful cloud services, device management, and advanced security in one, connected experience.

office.com/setup"

11:31 PM  
Blogger shiviwebh said...

Amazon Prime TV, and MyTV code. To register your device on the Amazon website you go to our website and enter the given code. The program requires the customer to have an Amazon account and a streaming device or TV. Amazon Prime Video is available on almost all streaming devices like Roku, Amazon Fire TV, Chromecast. For this, you just have to go to Amazon Amazon.com/mytv with the help of the amazon activation code. You can visit our website for details of the entire process. You can do this by installing the Amazon.com/mytv Video application on your smart TV, or the digital media player or video game console connected to your TV by visiting the link provided by us in the de cription.or more information, you can contact our team at Amazon.com/mytv and get more and more information.amazon.com/mytv

2:18 AM  
Blogger shiviwebh said...


Select the office product you want to download and install on the device. Go to the office.com/setup option. To upgrade Office, press on the products of office.com/setup and start downloading and installing Office products on the device.log in and enter office 25 digit product key to activate your office product. if you are new user then you need to create a office account to get more benefits of office.com/setup subscription.office.com/setup

2:19 AM  
Blogger shiviwebh said...


Roku Streaming players are an increasingly advantageous Roku.com/link and financially savvy approach to sit in front of the TV. Simply plug it into your TV, associate with the web, set up a Roku record, and start spilling your top choices.Roku gadgets are easy to set-up and simple to-utilize. roku/link They accompany a straightforward remote, and incredible highlights like Roku Search which makes it easy to discover what you need to watch.roku.com/link

2:19 AM  
Blogger shiviwebh said...

Norton Antivirus provides protection from viruses, malware, online threats without harming device performance. It also blocks harmful websites. You can get Norton.com/setup product from retail store and also download and install Norton Antivirus with product key from Norton.com/setup. And to do this, you can visit the website given by us at Norton.com/setup or link. Our entire team is available to help you.Norton.com/setup

2:19 AM  
Blogger shiviwebh said...

You can download and install norton setup from Norton.com/setup . Norton may receive annual renewal billing, cancellations, refunds, subscriptions, credit card updates, purchases by Norton membership. Visit Norton.com/setup to activate or renew your Norton membership. And a valid Norton membership ensures that your security is always updated. You should activate or renew your subscription before the trial or membership period ends so that all Norton features can continue to be used and your computer is protected. For more information, you can contact our team at Norton.com/setup and get more and more information.Norton.com/setup

2:19 AM  
Blogger Antivirus Tech Support said...

Kaspersky Anti-Virus features include real-time protection, detection and removal of viruses, trojans, worms, spyware, adware, keyloggers, malicious tools and auto-dialers, as well as detection and removal of rootkits

Kaspersky.com/activation
Kaspersky.com/activation
Kaspersky.com/activation
Kaspersky.com/activation
Kaspersky.com/activation
Kaspersky.com/activation

3:46 AM  
Blogger Antivirus Tech Support said...

Disney+ Hotstar is currently the most popular OTT service in India. Disney+ is a subscription-based streaming video service owned by Disney that’s similar to Netflix, Apple TV+, and Amazon Prime Video.

disneyplus.com/begin
disneyplus.com/begin

3:46 AM  
Blogger shilpiweb said...

Kaspersky Anti-Virus features include real-time protection, detection and removal of viruses, trojans, worms, spyware, adware, keyloggers, malicious tools and auto-dialers, as well as detection and removal of rootkits.
Kaspersky.com/activation
Kaspersky.com/activation
Kaspersky.com/activation
Kaspersky.com/activation
Kaspersky.com/activation
Kaspersky.com/activation

5:15 AM  
Blogger shilpiweb said...

Roku Streaming players are an increasingly advantageous roku.com/link and financially savvy approach to sit in front of the TV. Simply plug it into your TV, associate with the web, set up a Roku record, and start spilling your top choices.Roku gadgets are easy to set-up and simple to-utilize. roku/link They accompany a straightforward remote, and incredible highlights like Roku Search which makes it easy to discover what you need to watch.
roku.com/link
roku.com/link
roku.com/link

5:16 AM  
Blogger shilpiweb said...

Amazon Prime TV, and MyTV code. To register your device on the Amazon website you go to our website and enter the given code. The program requires the customer to have an Amazon account and a streaming device or TV. Amazon Prime Video is available on almost all streaming devices like Roku, Amazon Fire TV, Chromecast. For this, you just have to go to Amazon amazon.com/mytv with the help of the amazon activation code. You can visit our website for details of the entire process. You can do this by installing the Amazon.com/mytv Video application on your smart TV, or the digital media player or video game console connected to your TV by visiting the link provided by us in the de cription.or more information, you can contact our team at amazon.com/mytv and get more and more information.

5:16 AM  
Blogger yuvi said...

Select the office product you want to download and install on the device. Go to the office.com/setup option. To upgrade Office, press on the products of office.com/setup and start downloading and installing Office products on the device.log in and enter office 25 digit product key to activate your office product. if you are new user then you need to create a office account to get more benefits of office.com/setup subscription.
office.com/setup
office.com/setup

1:10 AM  
Blogger yuvi said...

You can download and install norton setup from Norton.com/setup . Norton may receive annual renewal billing, cancellations, refunds, subscriptions, credit card updates, purchases by Norton membership. Visit Norton.com/setup to activate or renew your Norton membership. And a valid Norton membership ensures that your security is always updated. You should activate or renew your subscription before the trial or membership period ends so that all Norton features can continue to be used and your computer is protected. For more information, you can contact our team at Norton.com/setup and get more and more information.
Norton.com/setup
Norton.com/setup
Norton.com/setup
Norton.com/setup
Norton.com/setup
Norton.com/setup

1:11 AM  
Blogger yuvi said...

Kaspersky Anti-Virus features include real-time protection, Kaspersky.com/activation detection and removal of viruses, trojans, worms, spyware, adware, keyloggers, Kaspersky.com/activation malicious tools and auto-dialers, Kaspersky.com/activation as well as detection and removal of rootkits.
Kaspersky.com/activation
Kaspersky.com/activation
Kaspersky.com/activation

1:11 AM  
Blogger yuvi said...

Roku Streaming players are an increasingly advantageous roku.com/link and financially savvy approach to sit in front of the TV. roku.com/link Simply plug it into your TV, associate with the web, set up a Roku record, and start spilling your top choices.Roku gadgets are easy to set-up and simple to-utilize. roku.com/link They accompany a straightforward remote, and incredible highlights like Roku Search which makes it easy to discover what you need to watch.
roku.com/link
roku.com/link

1:11 AM  
Blogger yuvi said...

Hulu is one amongst the foremost common streaming services, hulu.com/activate holding you watch movies, shows, live matches, and on-demand tv. the appliance provides additional importance to originals and new TV shows than to documentaries and flicks.

1:12 AM  
Blogger yuvi said...

Disney+ Hotstar disneyplus.com/begin is currently the most popular OTT service in India.disneyplus.com/begin Disney+ is a subscription-based streaming video service owned by Disney that’s similar to Netflix, Apple TV+, and Amazon Prime Video.

1:12 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

supreme shirt
hermes belt
jordan shoes
curry 7
moncler
off white nike
alexander mcqueen shoes
lebron james shoes
air jordan
birkin bag

2:04 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home