Thursday, May 10, 2012

It's Time to Reform Indigent Defense in Pennsylvania


Last month, the ACLU of Pennsylvania filed a lawsuit against Luzerne County because adult defendants are not receiving constitutionally required counsel due to an underfunded the Office of the Public Defender (OPD).  The attorneys are so overworked that they rarely have time to meet with clients before hearings, investigate clients' cases, or adequately prepare for trial.  The situation had grown so dire by December 2011 that the OPD started declining representation to individuals charged with less serious crimes.  Over 300 individuals with pending criminal charges in Luzerne County are now facing the criminal justice system without an attorney when they are constitutionally entitled to one.

Today our attorneys are in court seeking a preliminary injunction that would authorize filling vacancies in the Luzerene OPD, increase the budget for the OPD, and provide private lawyers for those 300 criminal defendants who face criminal trials without counsel.


The right to an attorney--no matter one's ability to afford one--has long been established. This past March marked the 49th anniversary of the Supreme Court's decision in
Gideon v. Wainwright, where the court declared that individuals with pending criminal charges have a fundamental right under the 6th Amendment to the U.S. Constitution to legal representation even when they cannot pay for it.  Despite this ruling, many people are forced to navigate the criminal justice system effectively unrepresented because public defender offices across the nation are overworked and underfunded.  A lack of representation can mean that no counsel is present or that the attorneys are so under-prepared that their efforts are essentially meaningless.

In Pennsylvania, we have witnessed the startling consequences of the failure to adequately fund public defender offices so that they can provide the representation required by the U.S. Constitution.
From 2003 to 2008 during the infamous "kids for cash" scandal, nearly 50% of the juvenile defendants who appeared in court in Luzerne County did not have attorneys because the Public Defender's Office lacked the resources to represent them.  This lack of representation coupled with two corrupt judges resulted in at least half of these juveniles being sent to detention facilities, many for offenses that didn't warrant such harsh punishment.

The reason that many of Pennsylvania's counties have a poor track record when it comes to providing constitutionally required counsel is because indigent defense (legal representation for individuals with pending criminal charges who cannot afford an attorney) is solely funded by the individual counties.  Pennsylvania is the only state that does not provide at least some state funding for indigent defense.  This leaves fundamental rights to the competition and whims of local political battles over meager resources in cash-strapped counties.  Clearly, it is time for the General Assembly to step in and vindicate the constitutional rights of indigent defendants in Pennsylvania by providing at least some funding for county public defender offices.  


For an in-depth look at the state of indigent defense in Pennsylvania, please see the December 2011 report of the Joint State Government Commission's Task Force and Advisory Committee on Services to Indigent Criminal Defendants entitled
A Constitutional Default: Services to Indigent Criminal Defendants in Pennsylvania:.

--Hilary Emerson, ACLU-PA Legal Fellow

Labels: , ,

8 Comments:

Anonymous Nemo said...

Did you know that the Public Defender Association of Pennsylvania (PDA) has its own plan in reaction to the recommendations in that JSGC report?

Did you know the PDA has adopted "aspirational" caseload standards?

Did you know that the PDA has also adopted uniform definitions of what constitutes a "case' so that data can be reliably compared statewide once the resources exist to gather it?

Did you know that the PDA has asked for legislative help in establishing The Pennsylvania Public Defender Center For Constitutional Criminal Defense?

4:58 PM  
Anonymous Nemo said...

Take a look at this:

http://www.scribd.com/doc/148010554/Public-Defender-Indigent-Defense-Statute-Pennsylvania-Criminal-Defense

11:48 AM  
Anonymous Nemo said...

Here is a plan that can be cost effective. Talk to your local legislators please.

http://www.scribd.com/doc/148418461/PDA-proposal-to-Address-Indigent-Defense-2013-Pennsylvania-Criminal-Defense

11:53 AM  
Blogger Monika said...

HBO Max is a stand-alone streaming platform that bundles all of Hbomax.com/tvsignin together with even more TV favorites, blockbuster movies, and new Max Originals for everyone in the family.DisneyPlus.com/Begin - is one of the most popular streaming services in the world right now. With the entire catalogue of Disney classics available, plus new favorites like Hamilton and exclusives like Muppets Now, it’s not hard to see why. But when it comes to technology, sometimes you need a little help to get going. One of the issues people are seeing now is a message prompt telling them to go to DisneyPlus.com/Begin or DisneyPlus.com/Start. Here is what to do if you see that message on your screen.Go to installturbotax.com to sign in or create an account, and then enter your activation code (even if you've already started your taxes for tax year 2020, you'll still need to activate the code). Select Continue and then select your state.Download install turbotax with license code desktop tax preparation software and do your taxes on your computer. Choose from Product activation required via Internet.Get your pay up to 2 days before payday with ASAP Direct Deposit!* Learn More Activate.turbotax.com · ACTIVATE CARD. installturbotax.com Track your refund. No Matter How Complicated, We Have You Covered. The simple, easy, and 100% accurate way to file taxes online.

7:38 AM  
Blogger Monika said...

HBO Max is a stand-alone streaming platform that bundles all of HBO together with even more TV favorites, blockbuster movies, hbomax.com/tvsignin and new Max Originals for everyone in the family.If you want to take full advantage of your Amazon Prime account please link it to your TV and thank us later. Simply head on over to amazon.com/mytv . Amazon Prime is a subscription service that caters to the media needs of people through the Amazon Prime platform. Amazon.com/mytv Notifies visitors about topics such as Register TV, Amazon Prime TV and MyTV code.If you want to protect your devices from harmful data, go to McAfee activate 25 digit code and download mcafee antivirus.Install mcafee product without any hassle. We provide best installation service ,It protect against virus ,click here www.mcafee.com/activate for more details.Protect your PC from virus, spam, spyware, and malware. McAfee provides the latest antivirus software, spyware removal and internet security for your home or home office.We provide best installation service for other information visit our website mcafee.com/activate by click here mcafee.com/activate and enjoy it.

7:46 AM  
Blogger Monika said...

If you want to take full advantage of your Amazon Prime account please link it to your TV and thank us later. Simply head on over to Amazon.com/code . Amazon Prime is a subscription service that caters to the media needs of people through the Amazon Prime platform. Amazon.com/code Notifies visitors about topics such as Register TV, Amazon Prime TV and MyTV code. To register your device on the Amazon website you go to our website Amazon.com/code and enter the given code.The Canon, the famous brand has everything in it's variety starting from their cameras, to cinematography solutions to the scanner as well as printers – each single thing has its own specific productivity.Download from ij.start.canon/setup and setup on your device. Canon printers are all in one printer that facilitates print, copy and scan. The canon printers are designed for personal as well as business use.www.amazon.com/mytv is the official Uniform Resource Locator from you can easily stream to exclusive amazon originals as well as popular movies, TV shows. Watch anytime, anywhere. www.primevideo.com/mytv is only accessible to only premium based members and have already subscribed for the primevideo.com/mytv , While Amazon users can start up for basic trial without needing a subscription, much of what you find on the Prime Video app requires a paid subscription.

7:48 AM  
Blogger Monika said...

The Canon, the famous brand has everything in it's variety starting from their cameras, to cinematography solutions to the scanner as well as printers – each single thing has its own specific productivity.Download from Canon.com/ijsetup and setup on your device. Canon printers are all in one printer that facilitates print, copy and scan. The Canon.com/ijsetup are designed for personal as well as business use.website to setup your printer. Get started withyour new printer by downloading the software.We Support you for www.123.hp.com/setup Network Printer Connection which can be done by either USB or Wireless Connection.website to www.123.hp.com/setup get started with your new printer by downloading the software.You will be able to connect the printer to a network and print across devices.DisneyPlus.com/Begin - is one of the most popular streaming services in the world right now. With the entire catalogue of Disney classics available, plus new favorites like Hamilton and exclusives like Muppets Now, it’s not hard to see why. But when it comes to technology, sometimes you need a little help to get going.amazon.com/mytv is the official Uniform Resource Locator from you can easily stream to exclusive amazon originals as well as popular movies, TV shows. Watch anytime, anywhere. Amazon Prime is only accessible to only premium based members and have already subscribed for the Amazon Prime Account.

7:50 AM  
Blogger Monika said...

If you want to protect your devices from harmful data, go to and download mcafee antivirus.Install mcafee product without any hassle. We provide best installation service ,It protect against virus ,click here mcafee.com/activate for more details.Norton Security Standard can protect only one system. Enter norton product key at norton.com . other way enter the Norton Setup Product Key. You can visit Norton's site to learn more about norton.com/setup and to compare them.Go to and if you're not already signed in, select Sign in. Sign in with the account you associated with this version of Office.Through office setup you can download, install and download app office.com/setup . create a Ms office account to manage and office 2019 subscription.Webroot SecureAnywhere Antivirus is a powerful antivirus, designed to fight malaria and other threats. You can protect your computer, PC, and other devices from malware, viruses, spyware, etc. You can download, install and install webroot via webroot.com/safe . website to setup your printer. Get started withyour new printer by downloading the software.We Support you for 123 hp com Setup Network Printer Connection which can be done by either USB or Wireless Connection.www.123.hp.com/setup website to setup your printer get started with your new printer by downloading the software.The Canon, the famous brand has everything in it's variety starting from their cameras, to cinematography solutions to the scanner as well as printers – each single thing has its own specific productivity.Download from Canon.com/ijsetup and setup on your device.

7:53 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home